500 faith-affirming questions that we find difficult to answer, or find secular answers unconvincing, so we put them on the ‘shelf’. Show your shelf by adding your questions to the list.
If Joseph Smith didn’t dictate the Book of Mormon, why are most errors in the original manuscript based on mishearing, and most errors from the printer’s manuscript based on misreading? Read more…
If Joseph Smith had previously written the Book of Mormon in his own time, where are all the drafts? Read more…
How would Joseph Smith have afforded all the paper to write drafts of the Book of Mormon when it was so expensive and scarce at the time? Read more…
If Joseph Smith had previously written the Book of Mormon before dictation, where did he find the time? Read more…
If Joseph Smith had previously written the Book of Mormon in his own time, why did no one notice? Read more…
If Joseph Smith had previously written the Book of Mormon before dictation, why would he go through all the effort of pretending to translate day after day? Read more…
What is our evidence that Joseph Smith had amassed a vast frontier library of alleged sources of the Book of Mormon? Read more…
How is Joseph Smith’s ungrammatical 1832 account of the first vision consistent with being the sole author of the Book of Mormon three years earlier? Read more…
Why did early critics of Joseph Smith consider him a “blockhead” but later critics consider him a “myth maker of prodigious talents”? If the Book of Mormon is a fraud, then which extreme view of Joseph is true? Read more…
Why would a religious man like Joseph Smith dare to write a fraudulent book which mentions Christ once every 1.7 verses? Read more…
If the Book of Mormon was written by someone else with expertise in Hebraisms, Mesoamerica etc., then who was it and what is our evidence? Read more…
Why would someone with expertise in Hebraisms, Mesoamerica etc. anonymously fabricate a long and complex story, then exclusively share it with a farm boy who isn’t interested in books? Read more…
If someone else wrote the Book of Mormon, why would they go to the effort of also supplying gold plates or require Joseph Smith to source them separately? Read more…
Would we expect approximately 1,500 shifts in author or source throughout the Book of Mormon? Read more…
How would Joseph Smith not get confused while dictating the Book of Mormon when the storyline started to include flashbacks within flashbacks? Read more…
If Joseph Smith wrote the Book of Mormon himself, why make it so long? Excluding Bible quotes it has 258,000 words (compared to 184,000 words in the New Testament). Why wouldn’t Joseph just write a much shorter book and take fewer chances of being exposed? Read more…
How could Joseph Smith (while dictating) manage to list a lengthy genealogy in Ether 1 and then discuss each person in reverse order throughout the rest of the book? Read more…
How could Joseph Smith manage to create three accounts of Alma’s conversion which are consistent with their having been written by a single individual, but in different settings and at different stages of his life? Read more…
How could Joseph Smith include 68 sermons in the Book of Mormon if he had never given a sermon in his life? Read more…
Would Joseph Smith have noticed the significance of the phrase “this day” from reading the Bible? Read more…
How should we account for what Hugh Nibley thinks is the most convincing evidence yet brought forth for the authenticity of the Book of Mormon (the Year-Rite)? Read more…
Where would Joseph Smith have learned all about the nature and importance of Jewish oaths? Read more…
Why would Joseph Smith say that Laman and Lemuel beat Nephi and Sam with a rod rather than using their fists? Read more…
If Joseph Smith was copying from the Bible, wouldn’t have he said “the city of Jerusalem” rather than “the land of Jerusalem“? Read more…
Is it by chance that there are meaningful similarities between the stone box containing the Nephite relics, and the Israelite Ark of the Covenant? Read more…
Why does the Book of Mormon mention veiled reference of seers who “saw and heard”? Read more…
Why would the name Sidon appear in the Book of Mormon, but not Tyre? Read more…
What are the odds that the symbol of the tree of life is supported by many other evidences from other ancient Near Eastern cultures, including Mesopotamia and Egypt? Read more…
Why does the Book of Mormon describe the ferocious Gaddianton robbers as wearing lamb-skin? Would we expect this rich symbolism if Joseph Smith wrote the book himself? Read more…
If Joseph Smith wrote the Book of Mormon himself, why are there other deep syntactic patterns that match the sixteenth century and are a poor fit for either the English of King James Bible or for eighteenth- and nineteenth-century imitations of biblical style? Read more…
If Joseph Smith wrote the Book of Mormon himself, why would he use the “plural was“? Read more…
Why does the Book of Mormon contain complex finite cause syntax which is utterly different from what we encounter in the King James Bible and pseudo-archaic texts? Read more…
Wouldn’t it have been easy for Joseph Smith to mistakenly include descriptions of armor consistent with the Bible or Rome (such as helmets)? Read more…
How could Joseph Smith keep track of at least 151 unique geographical relationships in the Book of Mormon? Wouldn’t we expect around 28 mistakes if Joseph tried to go into that much detail? Read more…
Why are the works of Shakespeare, Tolkien, and Rowling used to explain away the Book of Mormon, when none of those authors claimed to dictate their work, use their first draft or that their book was true scripture? Read more…
How was Joseph Smith so meticulous in the usage of sacred numbers such as Lehi’s seven tribes? Read more…
Why would Joseph Smith, a patriotic American, frame the American revolution in the Book of Mormon as a story of deliverance rather than of resistance? Read more…
If Joseph Smith wrote the Book of Mormon, wouldn’t we expect it to be less favorable to kingship like the political climate in early 19th century America? Read more…
Why would Joseph Smith take a chance on mentioning barley in the Book of Mormon? Read more…
Why would Joseph Smith mention bees in the Book of Mormon if it would only make readers skeptical? Read more…
Wouldn’t mentioning elephants in the Book of Mormon be an unnecessary risk for Joseph Smith? Read more…
Why is the list of purported anachronisms in the Book of Mormon continually getting smaller? If it was written by Joseph Smith, wouldn’t it look clumsier over time rather than being proved stronger? Read more…
Why would Joseph Smith say that the ancient inhabitants of Mesoamerica had fine fabrics, textiles and elaborate clothing when the Indians of Joseph Smith’s time and place wore clothing made primarily of animal skins? Read more…
Why would Joseph Smith say that the ancient inhabitants of America had chief marketplaces when the Indians of his day didn’t have marketplaces at all? Read more…
Where would Joseph Smith have found out about execution practices of North and Central American cultures going back to pre-Columbian times? Read more…
Why would Joseph Smith take a chance on mentioning the “great spirit” if it was believed to be anachronistic? Read more…
If Joseph Smith wrote the Book of Mormon himself, would we expect the four Mayan functions of “and it came to pass” to all appear in the text? Read more…
Why would Joseph Smith include the use of cement in ancient America? If he was trying to win over a 19th century audience, wouldn’t he have maintained the status quo? Read more…
Was it luck that Dr. Smith (who saved Joseph Smith’s leg and potentially his life) was likely the only physician in the United States in 1813 who had the expertise to successfully deal with Joseph Smith’s bone disease? Read more…
Why is there a “blatant pun” on the name Moses in the Joseph Smith translation of the Bible, before the Egyptian meaning of Moses’s name was known to scholars? Read more…
Isn’t it unexpected that the Book of Moses would contain the expression “Behold I“? Read more…
Why would Joseph Smith go against typical Jewish and Christian beliefs in his day by saying that the creation was the work of a divine council? Read more…
Why would Joseph Smith take a chance on mentioning chariots in the Book of Abraham? Read more…
Why wouldn’t Joseph Smith just agree with the Bible that Abraham was 75 when he went into the land of Canaan? Read more…
How could Joseph Smith correctly give the meaning of “Shinehah” in Abraham 3:13 (a word that applied during a narrow span of about 6 centuries comprising the likely time of Abraham’s life)? Read more…
Aren’t the chances that Joseph Smith made up a fictional, outlandish place (Olishem) that turned out to be accurate in name, time, and location too astronomical even to be considered? Read more…
How did Joseph Smith manage to restore ordinances from the early Church (such as baptisms for the dead), when no major religions in Joseph’s day believed in this doctrine? Read more…
Show Your Shelf is not in any way sponsored or endorsed by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. For official information from the Church please see churchofjesuschrist.org or comeuntochrist.org